VBOAT logo

What Is Weezer's Best Album of All Time?

cover of Weezer's green album

Weezer, man, what a trip. Formed in ’92 in the glitzy wilds of Los Angeles, these cats were like nothing else at the time. Rivers Cuomo, the bespectacled frontman, a veritable rock ‘n’ roll geek genius, with his nerdy demeanor and his hair all straight, grabbed that guitar and gave it a new voice. Together with Brian Bell, Patrick Wilson, and Matt Sharp, they conjured up a sound that was pure power pop but with a sharp and crunchy edge.

Their debut album, the “Blue Album,” man, it was like catching lightning in a bottle. “Buddy Holly,” “Say It Ain’t So,” “Undone – The Sweater Song” – songs that spoke to the freaks, geeks, lovers, and the lost. But it wasn’t all just sugar-coated candy; there was depth there, man, a real exploration of youth, longing, and identity.

’96 brought us “Pinkerton,” a twisted masterpiece that’s as uncomfortable as a bad trip at times. It’s raw, it’s personal, it’s messy. Critics slammed it, but the fans, the real fans, they got it. It’s a grower, not a shower, and it’s become a classic.

Then came the wilderness years, albums that tried to catch that old magic but sometimes missed the mark. But don’t write ’em off. Weezer kept pushing, kept playing, kept putting out tunes that catch you off guard with their infectious hooks and quirky lyrics.

Weezer’s like that weird friend who shows up at the party, maybe dressed a bit off, maybe saying things that make you raise an eyebrow, but you love ’em for it. They’re unapologetically themselves. They’re the nerds who got the last laugh, the oddballs who made good.

You dig Weezer or you don’t, and that’s cool, man. But if you get ’em, you really get ’em. They’re part of the tapestry of modern rock, a colorful, bold, and sometimes perplexing part, but essential all the same.

So here’s to Weezer, those purveyors of geek chic, those kings of the strange anthem, those poets of the awkward soul. But which collection of anthems would you rank as Weezer’s best?

Release Date Album Name AllMusic Score
1994 Weezer (Blue Album) 5/5
1996 Pinkerton 3/5 (The Guardian)
2001 Weezer (Green Album) 4.5/5
2002 Maladroit 4/5
2005 Make Believe 3/5
2008 Weezer (Red Album) NA
2009 Raditude 3.5/5
2010 Hurley 3.5
2014 Everything Will Be Alright in the End 4/5
2016 Weezer (White Album) 4.5/5
2017 Pacific Daydream 3./5
2019 Weezer (Teal Album) 3/5
2019 Weezer (Black Album) 4/5
2021 OK Human 4.5
2021 Van Weezer 3.5

What Is Weezer's Best Album?

More About Weezer Albums

Weezer, an American rock band formed in Los Angeles in 1992, has left an indelible mark on alternative rock and pop-punk. Their blend of catchy hooks, emotional lyrics, and a unique sense of geeky charm has endeared them to fans across generations.

Weezer (Blue Album)

The self-titled “Blue Album,” released in 1994, introduced Weezer to the world with its blend of power-pop and alternative rock.
  • Year Released: 1994
  • Notable Singles: “Buddy Holly,” “Say It Ain’t So,” “Undone – The Sweater Song”


“Pinkerton” (1996) represents a darker, more experimental phase for the band, filled with raw emotions and distinctive sound.
  • Year Released: 1996
  • Notable Singles: “El Scorcho,” “The Good Life”

Weezer (Green Album)

Weezer returned with the “Green Album” (2001), marking a shift back to a more polished, pop-oriented sound.
  • Year Released: 2001
  • Notable Singles: “Island in the Sun,” “Hash Pipe”


Released in 2002, “Maladroit” continued the band’s evolution, experimenting with heavier rock elements.
  • Year Released: 2002
  • Notable Singles: “Dope Nose,” “Keep Fishin'”

Make Believe

“Make Believe” (2005) brought commercial success with its polished production and catchy melodies.
  • Year Released: 2005
  • Notable Singles: “Beverly Hills,” “Perfect Situation”

Weezer (Red Album)

The “Red Album” (2008) showed a more experimental side of Weezer, with members sharing vocal duties.
  • Year Released: 2008
  • Notable Singles: “Pork and Beans,” “Troublemaker”


“Raditude” (2009) saw the band embracing pop trends, leading to some polarizing reactions from fans.
  • Year Released: 2009
  • Notable Singles: “If You’re Wondering If I Want You To (I Want You To)”


With “Hurley” (2010), Weezer returned to a more rock-oriented sound, with collaborative writing playing a key role.
  • Year Released: 2010
  • Notable Singles: “Memories”

Everything Will Be Alright in the End

Released in 2014, “Everything Will Be Alright in the End” marked a return to the band’s earlier sound, pleasing long-time fans.
  • Year Released: 2014
  • Notable Singles: “Back to the Shack,” “Da Vinci”

Weezer (White Album)

The “White Album” (2016) continued the trend of revisiting the band’s roots, with a summer-inspired sound.
  • Year Released: 2016
  • Notable Singles: “Thank God for Girls,” “King of the World”

Pacific Daydream

“Pacific Daydream” (2017) saw the band experimenting with a poppier sound, drawing mixed reactions.
  • Year Released: 2017
  • Notable Singles: “Feels Like Summer”

Weezer (Teal Album)

The “Teal Album” (2019) is a covers album, featuring Weezer’s unique take on various hits.
  • Year Released: 2019
  • Notable Singles: “Africa”

Weezer (Black Album)

The “Black Album” (2019) continued Weezer’s musical exploration, featuring a darker and more experimental approach.
  • Year Released: 2019
  • Notable Singles: “Can’t Knock the Hustle”

OK Human

“OK Human” (2021) represents a departure from the band’s typical sound, embracing orchestral arrangements and introspective lyrics.
  • Year Released: 2021
  • Notable Singles: “All My Favorite Songs”

Van Weezer

“Van Weezer” (2021) pays homage to the hard rock and metal bands that influenced Weezer, bringing a more guitar-driven sound.
  • Year Released: 2021
  • Notable Singles: “Hero,” “The End of the Game”